The Nightingale (Kristin Hannah)


In a word: Devastating

The Nightingale

I don’t necessarily mean that in a bad way. But, the setting is France during World War II, so you know it’s not going to be an upbeat beach read. This is the story of two sisters, Vianne and Isabelle, each of whom faces her own struggle to survive.

In German occupied France, food is scarce. French police cannot be trusted to protect their own citizens. Men are sent to hopeless battles, and women and children are not safe in their own homes. Neighbors snitch. Politicians capitulate. Friends disappear. The details of this novel are a reminder that war is hell, even when the fighting is far away. And in an environment of fear, corruption, and desperation, human relationships are complicated.

On a most personal level, reading novels like this is always helpful in a shaming kind of way; “experiencing” the suffering of others offers healthy perspective. It helps me realize the smallness of my daily complaints (Can’t lose 5 pounds of baby weight! Grocery store out of 50% less sodium green beans! Ugh, where are my Tic Tacs?). I also am reminded what a bubble of extravagant prosperity I live in, and without which I would probably die. Were scarcity to enter my world in such a way that I depended on my own canning to survive the winter, for example, my family and I would starve. The contrast between Vianne’s life and mine makes me feel humble and grateful.

It’s hard to read stories like this where evil is so stark. Tales of brutality and terror are easier to stomach when they happened long ago; I can write it off as “another time,” perhaps even feel that it’s only to be expected among primitive, uncivilized peoples. But stories of World War I and II are especially stomach-wrenching for me: these are people so much like us, who live in a recognizable world that is suddenly turned upside down. I think this is why novels from this time period are so powerful: against the backdrop of a horrifying moral landscape, stories of hope and human triumph shine even brighter.


5 thoughts on “The Nightingale (Kristin Hannah)

  1. shannon says:

    i just finished this and liked it, didn’t love it. super predictable, overly simplistic caricatures, and a little overwrought. i was moved to tears by the end, so i guess somewhere along the way i bought in. really excited about this blog!


    • I think your critiques are legitimate, and I had the same experience of being surprised by how much the ending affected me! I did appreciate a glimpse into the experience of French citizens during the war- the physical hardships, the sense of violation and helplessness at the German occupation. I thought the most interesting character was the German Captain Beck- a Nazi nice guy.

      I’ve heard that JoJo Moyes’ book The Girl You Left Behind is a similar plot that produces a more successful result. I’m excited to try it! (I’ll let you know how it is!)


      • shannon says:

        very true–for as much as i love wwii history, this is the first time i’ve ever thought seriously about the occupation in france.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s